Rev. F. Duever 1884
Rev. A. Baumhoefner 1890
Rev. August Mueller 1898
Rev. Walter Schmidt 1900's
Rev. L. Plehn 1900's
Rev. Karl Kretzschmar 1900's
Rev. William Landgraf 1900's
Rev. H. Wilkens 1900's
Rev. William J. Roesler 1918-1921
Rev. W.E. Scheer 1922-1927
Rev. O. Heilmann (vacancy) 1927-1928
Rev. Phil Wirth 1928-1933
Rev. Victor Hoffmann (vacancy) 1933
Rev. E.H. Hartman 1934-1935
Rev. F.W. Schultze 1935-1938
Rev. Edwin Friedrich 1938-1943
Rev. William Landgraf 1943-1950
Rev. Grant Krueckeburg (vacancy) 1950
Rev. Henry F. Krohn 1950-1953
Rev. Vern H. Albrecht 1953-1956
Rev. O.A.O. Graebner (vacancy) 1956
Rev. George Baumgartner 1956-1960
Rev. John Schwarting 1960
Rev. Arthur P. Bruenger 1960-1964
Rev. Eddwin Bek (vacancy) 1964
Rev. Howard W. Mueller 1965-1977
Rev. John Sievers (vacancy) 1978
Rev. Wendell R. Hamilton 1978-1983
Rev. R. Klein (vacancy) 1983
Rev. Roland W. Going (vacancy) 1983-1984
Rev. Rodney A. Armon 1984-2018
Rev. Daniel Bremer (vacancy) 2018-2019
Rev. Tyler Hauptmeier 2019-present